Dalia Elison's Market Report

Oyster Bay, NY 11771

Single-Family Homes

LuxuryHomeNY | dalia@luxuryhomeNY.com | 516.707.9022


Oyster Bay, NY 11771

Sat Oct 11 2025
This week the median list price for Oyster Bay, NY 11771 is $2,242,500 with the market action index hovering around 28. This is an increase over last month's market action index of 25. Inventory has decreased to 34. Click here to stay informed with the Oyster Bay market!

Market Action Index

This answers “How’s the Market?” by comparing rate of sales versus inventory.

Slight Buyer's Advantage

Market Narrative

Home sales have begun exceeding new inventory. This is a Buyer’s market so prices are not yet moving higher as excess inventory is consumed. If the tightening continues and the market moves into the Seller’s zone, we may see upward pressure on pricing.

Oyster Bay, NY 11771

Sat Oct 11 2025
This week the median list price for Oyster Bay, NY 11771 is $2,242,500 with the market action index hovering around 28. This is an increase over last month's market action index of 25. Inventory has decreased to 34. Click here to stay informed with the Oyster Bay market!

Market Action Index

This answers “How’s the Market?” by comparing rate of sales versus inventory.

Slight Buyer's Advantage

Market Narrative

Home sales have begun exceeding new inventory. This is a Buyer’s market so prices are not yet moving higher as excess inventory is consumed. If the tightening continues and the market moves into the Seller’s zone, we may see upward pressure on pricing.

Real-Time Market Profile

Never miss important changes in the Oyster Bay market.
Median List Price $2,242,500
Median Price of New Listings $0
Per Square Foot $598
Average Days on Market 172
Median Days on Market 119
Price Decreased 44%
Price Increased 0%
Relisted 6%
Inventory 34
Median Rent
Market Action 28
Slight Buyer's Advantage

Again this week we see prices in this zip code remain roughly at the level they’ve been for several weeks. Since we’re significantly below the top of the market, look for a persistent up-shift in the Market Action Index before we see prices move from these levels.

Market Segments

Each segment below represents approximately 25% of the market ordered by price.

Median Price Sq. Ft. Lot Size Beds Bath Age New Absorbed DOM
$7,100,000 7,500 1 - 2.5 acres 5 6.5 32 0 1 182
$3,135,000 6,117 2.5 - 5 acres 5 5.5 66 0 1 161
$1,870,000 3,400 8,000 - 10,000 sqft 5 3.5 54 0 0 84
$961,500 1,706 6,500 - 8,000 sqft 3 1.8 103 0 2 56